Regulating Social Media

Following a complaint to the Australia Advertising Standards Board, a judgment was made that comments by “fans” on Smirnoff Vodka’s Facebook page were considered “advertisements” and must therefore comply with industry regulatory codes and consumer protection laws.

The watchdog heard that a fan of the Facebook page commented that Smirnoff was “the purest Russian vodka” and would lead to success with the opposite sex. John Swinson, a partner at law firm King & Wood Mallesons explained to The Age that Smirnoff is Australian, not Russian and it may not be the purest. The comment also implies that you would have greater success with girls also contravenes Australian advertising codes. Industry codes not only apply to what a company posts on its Facebook page, but also to user-generated comments that followed. As the comments weren’t removed, Smirnoff was held liable for the actions of its “fan”.

Brands are increasingly relying on Facebook “word-of-month” to reach, not only fans, but also their social circles. There is currently very little legislation that governs the use of social media by brands and the decision handed down to Smirnoff just a few weeks ago has already caused havoc in the corporate world. Particularly for larger companies, constantly monitoring social media pages is impossible.

Activity can’t be completely controlled, but it can be managed. When a member of the public posts a complaint or an inaccurate statement on Facebook, companies need to respond immediately clarifying the issue. The problem facing corporations and their adverting agencies is that the Internet doesn’t close down at 5pm everyday nor does online activity cease over the weekend. If anything, user activity on social media increases after business hours. This poses a great challenge particularly to large corporations like Smirnoff who have a following of over 180 000 people.

Recent consumer trends would suggest that the risks of social media are only minor compared to its benefits. Consumers are increasingly using the Internet, and in particular Facebook, to research brands and products before making purchases. 85 per cent of Australians who are connected to the Internet use it as a resource to research, compare and seek advice about their shopping. 61 per cent use search engines, 50 per cent check the brand’s website, and 23 per cent use Facebook (source). I would challenge the last figure. Realistically, it is probably higher considering that a Google search will return the brand’s Facebook page and brand websites have links to their social media pages. Most consumers may not be going directly to Facebook, but they are certainly being directed there.

It is impossible to completely control the activity of users and fans, but strategies should be implemented to manage activity on public pages. Companies don’t have a choice: they need to be using social media as a marketing tool to positively promote their brands and now they must also comply with rapidly evolving standards and legislation.


5 thoughts on “Regulating Social Media

  1. You pose a very interesting and growing issue in the marketing world. As brands increasingly move towards media platforms to promote their products and company’s it is becoming more important for the brands image to remain in tact. With people given the ability to comment on and contribute to the marketing of the brand in an online social sphere, monitoring of the public’s behavior on the net is a necessity. New jobs therefore are being created in the area of IT to monitor the content that gets posted on the Internet in relation to the company’s image. Great post and very relevant to the digitalised marketing world!

  2. I completely agree with you and Bella. With many brands relying heavily on marketing their products through the use of facebook and twitter there has to be a lot more done to ensure that brands such as Smirnoff are not being tarnished by the public’s opinions which are being voiced on their respective pages.

  3. you raise some very good points: the internet doesn’t close down on weekends – so neither can organisations! is this a fair demand for businesses? To be held liable for what individuals post in a public forum? If anything, it discourages organisations from having an online presence at all.

  4. Yeah I really feel people who are consuming these so-called ads don’t actually see them as ads. Once you’ve liked a page on facebook, any correspondence with other members is just sharing the same views – as I see it anyway. But the fact is, any negative comments, truthful or not, affect the brand’s image once they go viral as we’ve seen through taunting remarks popping up in all our facebook feeds receiving thousands of ‘likes.’ The AASB (just quietly they took their acronym from an accounting regulatory body – but maybe I’ll blog about that) has in effect been ahead of the curve by banning things because negative comments hurt not only the macro advertising space, but it also hurts the concerned brand.

    A medium which once presented endless marketing potential has now been compromised – who knows what their next move will be!

  5. WOW! What a seriously interesting and well written post on an issue that’s increasingly monotonous in terms of reporting! Your analysis of the smirnoff brand’s dilemma is a perplexing one. While everyone seems to advocate the abolishment of the professional media sphere in wake of an increase of user generated consumer content, how on earth can it be regulated? More importantly, how is a massive organisation like smirnoff going to be able to manage such a vast enormity of user generated content, which they’re going to have to, because they’re being held liable for it! How can they hope to expand and advertise their brands when every comment has to be monitored! Ahh what a mess! So many questions! Fantastic Post!! x

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s